Doran and York question new building permit fee, want better infrastructure planning

GREAT BAY--Members of Parliament Egbert Jurendy Doran and Darryl York have raised concerns about Minister of VROMI Patrice Gumbs' proposal to introduce a third fee on building permits, questioning the financial burden on residents, government's revenue collection practices and the effectiveness of infrastructure planning and enforcement.
Speaking during Thursday's Central Committee meeting on national flood management, drainage and road infrastructure, both MPs challenged aspects of the Minister's proposed Urban and Environmental Development Fund, which would introduce an additional charge calculated according to the estimated value of construction projects.
Doran was particularly critical of the proposal, arguing that government should focus on collecting outstanding revenues before introducing additional financial obligations for residents already struggling with the cost of living.
The former VROMI Minister questioned why applicants should face another charge based on construction value when the existing building permit fee is already calculated using that figure.
He suggested that adjusting existing administrative fees would be more reasonable than introducing another charge linked to the same construction value.
Doran also questioned government's decision to dismantle a previous revenue collection task force, which he said had pursued outstanding payments from businesses, including longstanding debts. He argued that improving collection of money already owed should take priority over creating additional charges.
York took a somewhat different approach, acknowledging the need for sustainable infrastructure financing while questioning whether the proposed fee would fairly account for differences between homeowners, small businesses and major commercial developers.
He asked whether the Ministry was considering separate fee structures for residential and commercial construction, warning against imposing the same financial burden on ordinary residents and large developers undertaking projects for profit.
Beyond the proposed fee, Doran raised concerns about what he described as inconsistent enforcement of building regulations.
He questioned the status of a public-private infrastructure project in Sucker Garden, referring to earlier information indicating that work had proceeded without a signed agreement or the necessary documentation.
Doran contrasted that situation with the scrutiny faced by private developers and homeowners, including the West View project, which he said had been subjected to extensive permitting requirements.
He argued that government must apply the same standards to all developments, regardless of whether they involve private investors, public-private partnerships or individual homeowners.
York, meanwhile, focused on the technical planning and execution of infrastructure projects, questioning whether VROMI consistently applies established engineering standards when implementing road and drainage improvements.
He cited drainage interventions that he believes have created additional hazards because the solutions were not appropriate for the locations involved. He also questioned whether adequate drawings and technical assessments are prepared before contractors begin work.
The MP called for better coordination with utility companies, including GEBE, Telem and Flow, to develop a comprehensive inventory of underground infrastructure. He argued that existing utility records should be incorporated into government planning rather than repeatedly commissioning new assessments.
York also requested clarification on the Cole Bay drainage project, particularly whether the latest study addresses concerns about the proposed drainage route and its connection to the lagoon.
Both MPs questioned the effectiveness of infrastructure spending and the pace at which identified problems are being addressed.
Despite his concerns, York welcomed progress toward establishing a Road Fund, particularly the possibility of using it to finance major infrastructure investments rather than primarily covering routine operational expenses.
York, who has been working on his own legislative initiative concerning the Road Fund, confirmed that Gumbs had reached out to discuss their respective proposals. Although the meeting has not yet taken place, he welcomed the opportunity for cooperation, noting that both initiatives appear to be moving in a similar direction.
Join Our Community Today
Subscribe to our mailing list to be the first to receive
breaking news, updates, and more.



.jpg)

