A salute to liberty in the shadow of slavery

The Editor
November 16, 2026
•
Share this post

There is something deeply uncomfortable, yet historically revealing, about celebrating the 250th anniversary of a salute to American independence on an island where, in 1776, hundreds of people remained enslaved and countless others were being bought, sold and transported as human property.

That discomfort should not be dismissed. But neither should it prevent St. Eustatius from recognizing an event that secured its place in world history.

On November 16, 1776, the cannons of Fort Oranje answered a salute from the American vessel Andrew Doria. The exchange became celebrated as the first foreign acknowledgment of the new American flag. Whether it constituted formal diplomatic recognition is another matter, but its historical significance is undeniable.

The contradiction is equally undeniable.

The same island that acknowledged a revolution built around liberty was deeply involved in an economic system that denied liberty to Africans. The prosperity that made Statia the Golden Rock was intertwined with slavery, colonial commerce and the exploitation of human beings. We cannot celebrate one history while pretending the other happened somewhere else.

Yet there is another reality worth acknowledging. Statia Day belongs to the people of St. Eustatius. For many, the First Salute represents pride, international recognition and the remarkable influence of a small Caribbean island. Those sentiments are neither unreasonable nor inherently disrespectful to the memory of enslaved ancestors.

The St. Eustatius Afrikan Burial Ground Alliance, however, has raised questions that deserve serious consideration. They concern who determines how history is remembered, whether descendants have been meaningfully consulted, and what lasting benefit such celebrations bring to ordinary Statians. Those are legitimate questions.

The Dutch government maintains that the anniversary program was developed with community involvement and includes recognition of slavery through memorial projects, historical visits and discussions. The recent reburial of 69 ancestors and the unveiling of a mural honoring the island's 1848 freedom fighters also represent important steps toward a more complete public understanding of Statia's past.

But recognition cannot become a substitute for engagement. A government memorandum indicating that further discussions with the Alliance would not take place before the anniversary is particularly troubling. Disagreement should not disqualify people from being heard.

The King and the Dutch government have acknowledged the Netherlands' responsibility for slavery. Yet the difficult conversation must continue beyond memorials and ceremonies to questions about historical accountability, opportunity, housing, education and the economic challenges confronting Statia today.

Not every contemporary problem can be attributed directly to slavery. Equally, it would be intellectually dishonest to suggest that centuries of exploitation left no lasting consequences. What Statia needs is neither an uncritical celebration nor an outright rejection of its past. It needs the confidence to embrace the full complexity of its history.

The First Salute happened. Slavery happened. Resistance happened. Each deserves its rightful place in the island's story. Perhaps the greatest tribute to Statia's ancestors would be a future in which its people have a stronger voice in decisions affecting their lives.

Two hundred and fifty years later, the question should not simply be whether the cannons deserve to sound again. It should also be whether we are finally prepared to listen to the voices that were never heard when they first did.

‍

Share this post