Statia Helped Shape America. Recognition Should Shape Our Future.

By Alfred Harley
November 16, 2026
•
Share this post

As we mark 250 years since the First Salute, the question is how to honour that inheritance honestly and use the attention it brings to secure something lasting for the people who live here. However, in deference to some claims, Statia should not have to choose between mourning the suffering of its ancestors and celebrating its contribution to the American Revolution. Both belong to our history.

On November 16, 1776, the Continental Navy brig Andrew Doria arrived to obtain military supplies. Governor Johannes de Graaff ordered Fort Oranje to answer the ship’s thirteen-gun salute with eleven guns. The exchange is traditionally recognised as the first foreign salute to the American flag aboard an American warship. Formal Dutch recognition of American independence followed on April 19, 1782. De Graaff authorized a local salute without possessing the authority to determine the Dutch Republic’s foreign policy. That distinction matters, but it does not erase the significance of the act which occurred on Statia.

British officials understood the salute as favour towards the American rebels and an affront to their flag. De Graaff was summoned to explain his conduct and subsequently returned to his governorship. The political meaning of the exchange was evident to contemporaries, even without formal diplomatic recognition. The island’s contribution extended beyond that moment. Statia’s trading connections helped supply the American struggle. Merchants pursued profit, but commercial motives do not cancel the consequences of their transactions.

An island of roughly eight square miles played a consequential part in a revolution whose effects reached far beyond its shores. That achievement emerged from a society in which human beings were bought, sold and compelled to work without pay. Enslaved people helped sustain an economy whose prosperity they could not freely enjoy. Indeed, their lives, labor and resistance belong at the centre of our account of Statia, alongside its merchants, governors and international connections. Their labour should be recognised without suggesting that people forced to work had freely chosen to support the American cause.

The arrival of ships carrying enslaved Africans deserves remembrance, research and mourning. There is nothing to celebrate in their captivity. Preserving that history means recovering lives obscured by commercial records, protecting burial places and teaching future generations to recognize and resist dehumanization. Slavery existed before the salute and continued afterwards. American independence did not emancipate Statia’s enslaved people. We must acknowledge that contradiction without treating every event within the period as morally identical. Celebrating the island’s contribution does not endorse slavery or require admiration for everything de Graaff represented.

The salute neither created the system of enslavement nor ended it. People are entitled to question the form and emphasis of a public commemoration. Residents should help shape it, and disagreement deserves a hearing. But recognising one event does not inherently erase another, and to even suggest such is disingenuous. A fuller history gives us more to understand, it should not become a test requiring descendants to relinquish every source of pride associated with a painful past.

The consequences of Statia’s involvement also require precision. Britain declared war on the Dutch Republic on December 20, 1780, amid commercial and diplomatic disputes, including trade with the Americans and intercepted proposals for an American–Dutch treaty. Admiral Rodney captured and plundered Statia on February 3, 1781. The salute formed part of this troubled relationship, although it alone does not explain the war. But Statians are resilient and the island’s story did not end with its devastation. By 1792, nearly 300 ships a month, some carrying slaves, were again arriving, although exports to the Netherlands remained below earlier peaks. Later wars and changing commercial conditions contributed to renewed decline. Destruction, recovery and adaptation all belong to this island’s history.

This shared past gives Statia grounds to ask what recognition should mean today. Responsibility for British plunder remains British. The case for American participation rests on the contribution from which Americans benefited and the value of preserving that inheritance together. Historical gratitude can find practical expression in investment that serves Statia’s people. The anniversary should therefore not just be about remembering but also help bring American, Dutch and Statian institutions together around a sustained heritage programme. Oranje Bay offers a compelling starting point. Its surviving warehouses, waterfront structures and submerged remains preserve evidence of the commercial world that connected this island to the Atlantic.

Archaeological research documents their vulnerability to erosion and wave action. Protecting those remains could help tell the whole story, military supplies passing through the port, wealth accumulated through trade, and people whose freedom was denied while that wealth grew. Restoring a warehouse need not glorify its owner. It can reveal the work, exploitation and human experiences that made the building significant. The global discussion about reparations for the atrocities of slavery is already under way, with some world leaders acknowledging the need to address its lasting consequences. Statia can build on that with a program combining conservation with paid apprenticeships, scholarships, historical research and opportunities for local guides and businesses. Residents and descendant communities should collectively determine priorities and how ancestral history is presented, so that no single resident can claim to be spokesperson for an entire community.

November 16 can bring international attention to an island whose contribution deserves recognition, while creating opportunities to preserve histories that have received too little attention. The celebration can help finance the research, conservation and education needed to ensure that slavery’s brutality and its victims’ humanity are never forgotten. As descendants of enslaved people, we now sit at the table where decisions are made. We must step beyond the shadow of the chains our ancestors endured and use our voice and influence to help shape our future. That requires remembering their suffering honestly and pursuing the opportunities their struggle helped make possible.

We should speak firmly about injustice and demand accountability. But confrontation cannot be our only approach, and only recounting our ancestors’ suffering cannot be the full extent of our advocacy. The purpose of reparative justice should be to secure meaningful repair, rather than to assign inherited personal guilt or leave another generation defined principally by ancestral pain.

We must be prepared to negotiate, build partnerships and turn historical acknowledgment into tangible benefits such as compensation, educational opportunities, restored heritage and greater economic ownership. November 16 celebrations can create openings for that work. Recognising an achievement does not silence the history of slavery, and remembering slavery should not require us to surrender every occasion for pride. When we use those occasions to bring people together around concrete commitments, remembrance gains a lasting public purpose. Let us judge our advocacy by the dignity it protects, the opportunities it creates and the improvements it brings to people’s lives. Our ancestors’ suffering must remain part of our history; it must not become the limit of our ambition.

Alfred Harley

‍

Share this post