Caribbean seniors, the tax question, and the future of retirement
Across the Caribbean, the question of how societies support their elderly is moving steadily to the center of public debate. As populations age and pension systems strain under demographic pressures, tax policy has become one of the quiet but decisive tools shaping the lives of older citizens. From islands that have abolished income tax entirely to countries that carve out targeted exemptions or allowances, the Caribbean presents a patchwork of approaches to senior taxation.
For St. Maarten, the issue is particularly pressing. Seniors here do not receive a blanket exemption from income tax, but they do benefit from an elderly allowance, targeted filing support for low-income retirees, and a special pensionado regime designed to attract foreign retirees. The result is a system that offers some relief, but falls short of the sweeping exemptions seen in other parts of the region.
π πππ π’π¨π§ π¨π ππ¨π§ππ«ππ¬ππ¬
The Caribbean is home to some of the most favorable tax regimes in the world, and seniors naturally benefit where income tax has been eliminated altogether. St. Kitts and Nevis abolished personal income tax in 1980. Antigua and Barbuda followed in 2016, while the Bahamas, Cayman Islands, Turks and Caicos, and Bermuda also operate without personal income tax. For retirees in these jurisdictions, age matters less than geography: the absence of tax applies universally.
Other territories, however, maintain traditional tax systems but carve out reliefs specifically for older citizens or those on pension income. Jamaica grants both an age relief allowance and a pension exemption, together creating a significant tax-free threshold for those over 65. Barbados provides a higher personal allowance for those 60 and older receiving pensions, along with rebates on land tax for pensioners who meet certain criteria. Saint Lucia, in a reform scheduled to take effect in 2025, will exempt all pension income from taxation.
Some countries extend relief in narrower ways. Guyana allows residents 60 and older to be exempt from withholding tax on savings interest, provided their income falls under statutory limits. In Trinidad and Tobago, property tax deferrals exist for seniors receiving a state pension, though no general income tax relief is granted purely for age.
ππ. ππππ«πππ§βπ¬ ππ©π©π«π¨πππ‘
St. Maarten sits somewhere in between these models. Its system offers three notable elements:
Elderly Allowance: Citizens aged 60 and above can deduct a fixed elderly allowance from taxable income. This reduces tax liability but does not eliminate it.
Pensionado Regime: Retirees, particularly those moving to Sint Maarten, may qualify for a favorable regime under strict conditions. Applicants must be at least 50, have lived abroad for five years prior, and purchase an owner-occupied home valued at a minimum of ANG 450,000 within 18 months of registration. For those who qualify, foreign-sourced pension and investment income can be taxed at a reduced flat rate, often around 10 percent.
Tax Assistance Program: Seniors with annual income under ANG 18,000 are eligible for free government assistance in filing their returns. While this does not waive tax obligations, it helps reduce administrative burdens for low-income retirees.
This mix of relief, targeted incentives, and compliance support means that Sint Maarten neither offers the most generous regime in the Caribbean nor leaves seniors entirely unassisted. It represents a middle path, granting targeted relief without undermining government revenue.
πππ²π¨π§π ππ¨π₯π’ππ²: ππππ₯-ππ¨π«π₯π ππ¦π©π₯π’ππππ’π¨π§π¬
Numbers on paper tell only part of the story. For seniors in Sint Maarten, the cost of living is the measure that matters most. Groceries, utilities, and healthcare are all consistently higher than regional averages due to import dependence and limited economies of scale. A retiree living on a modest pension, say Xcg 25,000 annually, will still be taxable after allowances. Even a small deduction provides limited relief against expenses that climb steadily each year.
In Barbados, where a land tax rebate can cover up to 60 percent of a pensionerβs property taxes, the relief directly touches one of the biggest costs of retirement: housing. Jamaicaβs pension and age allowances, which combine to exempt more than J$2 million of income, give breathing room to retirees in a society where many still work informally into their later years.
By contrast, Sint Maartenβs assistance program with an income cap of ANG 18,000 is helpful for the very lowest-income seniors but leaves a wide gap for those slightly above the threshold. These households may not be βpoorβ by tax standards, but they are still vulnerable to the islandβs high consumer prices.
In its 2025 Article IV report for Sint Maarten, the IMF staff noted that the islandβs social insurance systems, particularly health insurance, are running persistent deficits, and recommended that reforms be βexpedited β¦ to avoid further depletionβ of reserves.
The same report called for mobilizing additional revenues to create space for priority spending. Suggested measures included improving tax compliance, introducing or adjusting levies such as a tourism tax, and targeting sectors that are currently under-taxed, including short-term rentals.
A separate study on social security in Sint Maarten by SEO concluded that retirement income does not suffice for many elderly households. The report found that nearly one quarter of households live on less than 80 percent of the minimum wage. These findings show that many seniors are already financially stretched, placing pressure on governments to consider more generous relief. At the same time, they underline the reality that such relief must be balanced with fiscal sustainability.
The Inter-American Development Bank IDB has also warned that in many Latin America and Caribbean countries, public spending for the elderly (on pensions, healthcare, long-term care) is forecast to grow faster than revenues unless systems are restructured: expanding coverage, improving efficiency, and recalibrating benefits are among the measures the Bank recommends.
The strength of Sint Maartenβs regime lies in its balance. By avoiding full exemptions, it reduces the fiscal risk of cutting off an important revenue stream. At the same time, the elderly allowance and pensionado regime recognize that older citizens and retirees face specific financial challenges. The filing support program for those below ANG 18,000 reflects a recognition of administrative fairness, ensuring low-income seniors are not disadvantaged by paperwork and compliance hurdles.
The shortcomings, however, are equally visible. The elderly allowance is modest and does not shield many seniors with modest but steady income. The pensionado regime, while attractive, caters mainly to wealthier foreign retirees with the means to purchase high-value property. The filing assistance programβs income cap excludes many retirees who are above the threshold but still vulnerable to rising living costs.
ππ‘π ππππππ π¨π§ ππ‘π ππ¨π«π’π³π¨π§
Taxation of seniors cannot be separated from the regionβs demographic and fiscal future. Caribbean populations are aging, healthcare costs are rising, and public pension systems face funding shortfalls. The Inter-American Development Bank has warned that unless governments act, pension sustainability will be threatened within a generation.
In this context, blanket tax exemptions for seniors may prove financially unsustainable. Governments will need to find middle-ground policies: raising thresholds, targeting relief to low- and middle-income seniors, or tying exemptions to specific costs like housing and healthcare rather than eliminating taxes wholesale.
Across the Caribbean, the treatment of seniors in tax systems varies from total exemption through abolished income tax to carefully targeted allowances and regimes. St. Maartenβs approach is neither the most generous nor the harshest. It reflects a compromise: acknowledging the needs of its elderly population and positioning itself to attract foreign retirees, while protecting the revenue base needed to sustain public services.
But as populations age, compromises may not be enough. The challenge for Sint Maartenβand for the Caribbean more broadlyβis to build systems that reflect the dignity of their elders, balance fiscal responsibility with fairness, and adapt tax policies to the real costs seniors face in daily life. The choices made now will determine not only the retirement years of todayβs seniors but also the financial security of generations to come.
β